Wenzhou's
Success Story
By
staff reporter ZHAN NI
A Delixi Electric production line. |
AN extraterrestrial landed in China one day
causing a sensation across the country. A politics-savvy Beijinger
probed him about the relationship between terrestrials and extraterrestrials.
An expo-oriented Shanghainese asked for his cooperation in running
an extraterrestrial exhibition. A gourmet Cantonese invited
him to a banquet in Guangzhou. Then a businessman from Wenzhoun
interposed, "Wait, may I have a word please? Can we do
business on your planet?"
This is a joke widely told in Wenzhou, and
gives an accurate image of the local people.
Origins of Wealth
Located in the southeastern corner of Zhejiang
Province, Wenzhou has been a migrant city since ancient times.
Having been forced to develop a mobile lifestyle, the local
people also nurtured an adventurous spirit. Remote from the
imperial capital, this small town was little influenced by the
orthodox Confucian culture, which advocated agriculture and
denigrated commerce. It was rather the regional Yongjia School
and its philosophy of material gain coupled with humanity that
dominated the mentality and outlook of the local Wenzhou people.
They were thus equipped with business sense and a commercial
culture more dominant than anywhere else in China.
The municipal government yearbook shows that
the number of Wenzhou citizens owning businesses in other parts
of China and abroad totals 1.6 million. Wenzhou businesspeople
are in all parts of the world: Brazil, the U.S., Italy, Japan,
the ROK, the Philippines, and France. By the end of 2002, the
number of private businesses in Wenzhou accounted for more than
90 percent of the total, and their industrial output value of
200 billion yuan made up 85 percent of the city's total. According
to a local official, Wenzhou has two economic characteristics:
it was the earliest to launch a market economy, and has the
most active and developed private economy in China.
Surviving Adversity
Wenzhou, a light-industry giant of
the future. |
Shoemaking has a long history in Wenzhou.
As early as the Chenghua Reign (1465-1488) of the Ming Dynasty,
Wenzhou boots were sent to the capital as an imperial tribute.
In the 1930s, leather shoe manufacture developed rapidly in
the city, and its products sold well across the country. In
the 1970s Wenzhou's high-heeled leather shoes dominated the
national market, winning it fame as China's City of Shoes.
The development of shoemaking gave rise to
an increase in the number of shoe manufacturers in Wenzhou,
including a number of frauds. For a time stories of poor quality
Wenzhou shoes spread around China, causing them to be shunned
by Chinese consumers.
August 8, 1987 was a day of humiliation for
Wenzhou's shoemaking industry. In Wulin Square, Hangzhou, neighbor
city to Wenzhou, 5,000 pairs of flawed Wenzhou leather shoes
were publicly burnt. "That fire also incinerated Wenzhou's
reputation," says Wang Zhentao, then a young Wenzhou shoe
dealer doing business in Hubei Province. The debacle kindled
his determination to start his own shoemaking business and redeem
the reputation of Wenzhou businesspeople.
Wang believed that his success would come
from design concepts. He traveled to Italy and other countries
in Europe every year, visiting his counterparts and studying
the market. Years later he set up an office and design and development
center in Italy where he hired experienced local designers to
ensure his products were in line with the world trend. Today
Chinese and overseas shoe designers at the Aokang Group work
with the advanced CAD system, pooling their artistry and drawing
inspiration from one another.
Within a period of 13 years, Wang's business
has developed from a rural workshop to a shoemaking group with
net assets of 300 million yuan.
Qian Jinbo's Hong Qing Ting company is another
private shoe manufacturer that emerged from Wenzhou. Qian Jinbo
was a late-comer to the shoe industry in 1995 when he started
his company in his hometown, Wenzhou's Yongjia County. He decided
to build up a corporate image based on quality and also on a
"shoe culture," an approach none of his predecessors
had tried. He was successful, and created a miracle in China's
shoe industry within seven years of development. Now his company
has grown into a group, and the Hong Qing Ting brand has been
exempted from inspection by the State Bureau of Quality and
Technical Supervision. Its current annual sales amount to 830
million yuan.
From Family Enterprise to Enterprise Family
There are few businesses in Wenzhou that do
not start as a family operation. The expansion of production
and China's entry into the WTO mean, however, that businesses
are making the transition from family orientation to modern
management.
The Chint Group Corporation is an outstanding
example of the success of such transition. Nan Cunhui, chairman
of the board, says, "We realized after fulfilling a certain
level of capital accumulation that it was only by transforming
ourselves from a family enterprise to an enterprise family that
we could make the leap from product to capital management."
Nan Cunhui and his friend Hu Chengzhong started
Chint in 1984 at an initial investment of 50,000 yuan. Today
it is a shareholding business. Chint has 106 shareholders, a
negligible number of whom are family, the largest non-family
member owning an equity interest worth tens of millions of yuan.
Although the group still maintains a familial tinge as regards
equity and intelligence structure, its operation strictly follows
the rules of shareholding enterprises. Nan Cunhui's aim is to
build Chint into a public corporation.
A Hong Qing Ting Group workshop. |
Across the street from Chint is the Delixi
Group. The two are known as the dual heroes of Chinese private
enterprises. They rank fifth and sixth respectively among the
top 500 private enterprises in China. After an initial period
of partnership, the two enterprises became fully fledged and
entered into strong competition. Nan Cunhui describes their
relationship as one of friendly rivalry, where both need to
be on their toes, and one constantly tries to outdo the other.
Delixi goes in for diversified development, while Chint concentrates
on specialization.
According to Nan Cunhui, Wenzhou's industry
would be non-existent without family enterprises. In order to
develop, however, these enterprises must break the family mode.
The Role of the Government
During the Wenzhou International Light Industry
Fair in October 2002, Baoxiniao Garments opened a store in the
center of the city, at which Wenzhou's mayor, Qian Xingzhong,
performed the ribbon-cutting ceremony. As long as they pay for
such invitations it is not difficult for businesses in Wenzhou
to induce municipal government officials to attend their business
activities. Payments do not, however, go to participating officials.
Wenzhou's open-minded municipal government has never been averse
to offering public support to businesses, but it has put these
occasions and the fees they charge for them to the public good.
Charges for ribbon-cutting by officials is collected through
the government's financial channel and goes into a special public
welfare fund. It is reported that annual contributions to the
fund amount to several million yuan.
Mayor Qian Xingzhong looks more like a scholar
than a government official. He compares the function of the
municipal government to that of a service institution, and sees
its role as allowing private businesses the freedom to develop,
while supporting and guiding them. What the government has done
is to create a stable social and policy environment in which
private businesses can grow. When they reach a certain scale,
it sets up new platforms for their further development, such
as the Wenzhou Digital City, the High and New Technology Park
and the Overseas Chinese Student Enterprise Park, which contribute
considerably to the city's industrial upgrading. The government
also provides market information, collects and provides economic
development information, and popularizes knowledge about the
WTO. To businesspeople in Wenzhou, the government is their information
center and liaison office.