
The Olympics Park for the 2008 Beijing
Olympic Games is currently under construction. |
Perplexities
It is no easy matter, building a super-size
ancient capital city. Beijing faces many difficulties in balancing
construction and preservation, and cases have occurred where
construction has been the cause of the destruction of cultural
relics.
There are those that complain that the charm
of old Beijing is gradually disappearing as grand buildings,
looming flyovers and laned expressways continue to emerge, yet
despite the emergence of clusters of modern buildings, it is
still hard to find a suitable venue for large international
conferences, such as for APEC and the Fortune Forum. In some
countries, construction of skyscrapers has been suspended, but
in Beijing, many advocate the construction of buildings of between
300 and 500 meters in height, the Oriental Plaza and China Grand
Theater being two such controversial construction projects.
According to municipal plans, buildings along
Chang'an Avenue, particularly those flanking the Gate of Heavenly
Peace (Tian'anmen), should not exceed a height of 30 meters.
The Oriental Plaza, along Chang'an Avenue to the east of Tian'anmen,
however, stands 50-60 meters tall, dwarfing the vermilion gate
and the Great Hall of the People. Wu Liangyong considers it
"an abomination."
The China Grand Theater to the west of the
Great Hall of the People was designed by French architect Paul
Andrew, and construction started in December 2001. It has an
area of 18,000 square meters and is covered by a titanium and
glass roof that gives it the appearance of a huge egg. There
were criticisms of the decision to place such a strange-looking
modernity by the side of the solemn Great Hall of the People
and Chang'an Avenue. "It is failure of huge proportions,
as regards its design in pursuit of form, damage to its function,
and aspects of waste and disproportion," says Liu Xiaoshi.
Others, however, have indicated their approval at such a form,
which, they say, has neither duplicated the structures nearby,
nor caused any conflict, while the current lack of public acceptance
is altogether a separate matter. Like the White Pagoda in the
Beihai Park, also an alien structure, people will gradually
come to accept it. "Beijingers will never ultimately refuse
things foreign," they conclude.

The 21st Universiade Village has
been converted into a students' dormitory area. |
Ping'an Avenue runs parallel to Chang'an Avenue.
Two years after opening to traffic, the street still looks staid
and lacking in vitality, and its low, ancient-style grey houses,
with too much emphasis on tradition, and the lack of parking
space, have been blamed. Ping'an Avenue's critics say that a
modern city should be in tune with the times, and that tunnel-vision
imitation of ancient architecture can only create "ghost"
streets.
Another controversy is the Beijing Central
Business District (CBD), currently under construction. When
completed, this 40,000-square-kilometer area will accommodate
200,000 people. Some criticize the CBD as being too close to
the city center, saying that the 200,000 people simultaneously
going in and out will exacerbate the already appalling traffic
congestion in the area. Others question the wisdom of erecting
a 300-meter high building in the area. Outspoken Wu Liangyong
describes the CBD as "a new cancer."
Despite many controversies, municipal
officials, city planners and architects have learned a lot from
the experience and lessons of the past 50 years, which will
enable them to build a more beautiful Beijing. It is reported
that a new plan to build Beijing into a cosmopolis has passed
the examination and approval of the Chinese Ministry of Construction.
It is hoped that when the plan is implemented, Beijing will
become a genuine cosmopolis in terms of economy, culture and
international exchanges.